Ka yi imani da mata

Ka yi imani da mata
slogan (en)

"Ka yi imani da mata" wata taken siyasa ce ta Amurka wacce ta fito ne daga ƙungiyar #MeToo . Yana nufin karɓar zarge-zargen mata na cin zarafin jima'i ko cin zarafin mata a darajar fuska. Maganar ta karu da shahara don mayar da martani ga Zaben Brett Kavanaugh a Kotun Koli.

Jude Doyle, a rubuce-rubuce ga Elle, ya yi jayayya cewa kalmar tana nufin "kada ku ɗauka mata a matsayin jinsi musamman masu yaudara ne ko masu ramawa, kuma ku gane cewa zarge-zargen ƙarya ba su da yawa fiye da na ainihi".

Tattaunawa da "Ku yi imani da dukan mata"

Rebecca Traister, a rubuce don The Cut, ta kira wannan magana "mai tilasta amma mara kyau": sau da yawa ana sake shi a matsayin "yi imani da dukan mata", kuma ana amfani da shi azaman "mai zurfi" da "mai mahimmanci" wanda ya "raƙatar da gardamar da ta fi muhimmanci cewa ya kamata mu ƙarfafa su su suyi magana da yawa, kuma mu saurare su da muhimmanci lokacin da suke magana".

Ku yi imani da duk mata" wani nau'i ne mai rikitarwa na wannan magana. Monica Hesse da ke rubutawa ga The Washington Post ta yi jayayya cewa taken koyaushe "yi imani da mata", kuma cewa "yi imani ga dukkan mata" bambancin shine "wani ɗan gaslighting na ilimin lissafi", mutum ne wanda masu sukar suka kirkira don a iya kai farmaki, kuma wannan madadin taken, ya bambanta da "yi imani na mata", "yana da tsayi, yana da gogewa, kuma ya bar ɗan ƙaramin wuri don nuance". Dan jaridar Libertarian Robby Soave da ke rubutawa don Reason bai yarda da wannan fassarar ba, yana jayayya cewa "#Masu ba da shawara na MeToo sun bukaci a yi imani ga kowanne mutum da ya yi iƙirarin cewa shi ne wanda aka azabtar da shi: watau, ya yi imani da dukkan mata". Ya lura cewa Susan Faludi na The New York Times ta yarda cewa "ta haɗu da wasu mata waɗanda suka yi kama da gaske suna biyan kuɗi ga fassarar hashtag ɗin".

Tattaunawar gaba ɗaya

Yin amfani da bambancin "dukan mata" na taken, Megan McArdle, marubuciya da ta bayyana kanta a matsayin "mai goyon bayan 'yanci", ta ba da shawarar a cikin wani shafi na ra'ayi na Bloomberg na 2017 cewa yanayin ya haifar da sakamako ga waɗanda ake zargi da mummunar hali na jima'i na "hukuncin mutuwa na tattalin arziki" - dakatar da aiki da tasiri baƙar fata daga filin su - a cikin abubuwan da suka faru wanda McArdle ya kall kamar yadda ba a bayyane ba a kafa shi ba, ko kuma ya haɗa da halayen da ba su da ba su ba su da tsanani.

A cewar The Atlantic, karɓar doka a Burtaniya, bisa ga abin da ya kamata 'yan sanda suyi imani da rahotanni na cin zarafin jima'i kuma suyi la'akari da masu korafe-korafe su zama wadanda abin ya shafa, ya haifar da binciken da ba daidai ba na' yan sanda game da da da'awar da kuma yin watsi da shaidu masu sabawa, wanda ya haifar da rushewar tuhuma.

Babu wani wuri a cikin shari'ar aikata laifuka

A cikin sabon wankewar 'yan wasan Hockey Canada 5, mai shari'a Maria Carroccia ta yanke hukuncin cewa:

"Although the slogan “Believe the victim” has become popularized of late, it has no place in a criminal trial. To approach a trial with the assumption that the complainant is telling the truth is the equivalent of imposing a presumption of guilt on the person accused of sexual assault and then placing a burden on him to prove his innocence. That is antithetical to the fundamental principles of justice enshrined in our constitution and the values underlying our free and democratic society."

Joe Biden da ake zargi da cin zarafin jima'i

A watan Afrilu na 2020, 'yan siyasa da masu sharhi da yawa sun tattauna zargin Joe Biden na cin zarafin jima'i dangane da taken "Ku yi imani da mata". Wakilin Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez ya soki abin da ta dauka a matsayin rashin mutunci da ya shafi batun: "Idan kuma muna so mu sami mutunci, ba za ku iya cewa ba za ku sani ba - duka biyu sun yi imani da mata, ku goyi bayan duk wannan, har sai ya dame ku, har sai hakan ya dame mu. " National Review ya soki abin ya yi la'akari da munafuncin Biden a cikin "bukinsa cewa Amurkawa dole ne su yi imani da mace a matsayin batun da ba za a iya motsawa ba" a lokacin zaben Kavanaugh. Editocin sun ce, "muna fatan cewa wannan lamarin ya koya wa Biden cewa hanyar da ya gabata game da zarge-zargen cin zarafin jima'i tana da haɗari, ba ta da 'yanci, kuma a ƙarshe ba za a iya jurewa ba". A gefe guda, Sanata Kirsten Gillibrand ya tsaya a kusa da Biden kuma ya ce, "Lokacin da muka ce 'yi imani da mata', don wannan niyyar tabbatar da cewa akwai sarari ga dukkan mata su zo gaba don yin magana da gaskiyar su, don a ji su. Kuma a wannan zargi, wannan shine abin da Tara Reade ta yi.