Kisan kiyashi na Jalan Turi

A daren 23 ga Afrilu 1992, a wani bungalow a Jalan Turi, Kuala Lumpur, babban birnin Malaysia, wani dangin Indiya-Amurka da baiwarsu sun kai hari daga jami'an tsaro. Kodayake uwargidan iyali ta tsere wa harin, 'ya'ya maza biyu na iyali - Arjun Talwar da Kabir Talwar - da uwarginsu ta Filipino Natalia Fernandes (wanda aka fi sani da Natty) masu gadi, Ariffin Agas, wanda aka kama a ranar kisan kiyashi sun kashe su. Ariffin, wanda ya yi iƙirarin cewa ƙungiyar 'yan kasar Sin uku ne suka kashe wadanda abin ya shafa kuma ya musanta duk tuhumar, an same shi da laifin kisan wadanda aka kashe uku kuma An yanke masa hukuncin kisa a watan Maris na shekara ta 1994. An yi watsi da roko na Ariffin kuma an rataye shi a ranar 27 ga Disamba 2002.

Kashewa sau uku

A ranar 23 ga Afrilu 1992, wani dangin Indiyawan Amurka (wanda ya zo daga New York) da uwargidan su sun sha wahala daga mummunan hari da jami'an tsaro suka fara.

Lokacin da harin ya fara ne kafin tsakar dare, Suneeta Talwar mai shekaru 38, Landan mijinta mai shekaru 44 Rakesh Talwar (darakta na Colgate-Palmolive) ke kan tafiya ta kasuwanci zuwa London, kawai ta dawo gida daga tafiya tare da abokai, kuma 'ya'yanta maza biyu da ma'aikaciyar Filipino suma suna nan a gida. Bayan ta dawo gida, jami'an tsaro sun kai wa Suneeta hari. Suneeta, wacce ta ji rauni, da kyar ta tsere daga gidanta da rai kuma ta tafi gidan maƙwabci don neman taimako. An gabatar da rahoton 'yan sanda kuma an kama wanda ake zargi a ofishinsa. 'Ya'yan Suneeta maza biyu da baiwarta ba a ko'ina ba za a iya samun su a cikin gidan, amma gidan yana da jini a ko'in wurin.

Wadanda aka kashe guda uku, wadanda aka gano su ne 'ya'ya maza biyu na Suneeta - Kabir Talwar mai shekaru 11 da Arjun Talwar mai shekara bakwai - da kuma yarinya mai shekaru 45 mai suna Natalia Fernandes (wanda aka yi kuskuren zama dan Indiya da farko), daga baya aka gano su sun mutu a cikin tankin septic, tare da jikinsu a saman juna daya da daya. Mai tsaron, wanda kawai ya fara aiki ga iyalin kwana uku da suka gabata, ya jagoranci 'yan sanda zuwa tankin kanta, kuma daga baya aka kama shi saboda kisan kai, kuma an sanya Sufeto Jami'in Sheridan Mohammad a matsayin mai kula da binciken. An kuma kai Suneeta Cibiyar Kiwon Lafiya ta Pantai don magani. An sanar da Rakesh mutuwar 'ya'yansa maza yayin da yake Landan, kuma a cikin sa'o'i biyu masu zuwa, Rakesh ya shiga jirgin sama zuwa Malaysia tare da abokinsa da likitoci biyu don tantance halin da ake ciki. Bayan kammala gwaje-gwaje bayan mutuwa, daga baya aka dawo da gawarwakin 'yan uwan Talwar zuwa Bombay (Mumbai na yanzu) don a binne su tare da bukukuwan jana'izar karshe.

A ranar 8 ga Mayu 1992, mai tsaron tsaro mai shekaru 25 Ariffin Agas, wanda ya zo daga Kuala Lipis, Pahang, an tuhume shi a kotu da kisan 'yan uwan Talwar biyu da baiwarsu. An gudanar da sauraron farko a watan Yulin wannan shekarar. An kammala sauraron farko a wannan watan, bayan kotun majistare ta umarci Ariffin da ya tsaya a gaban shari'a ga dukkan tuhume-tuhumen kisan kai guda uku don mutuwar 'yan uwan Talwar da Natalia.

An shirya shari'ar Ariffin ne a ranar 18 ga Oktoba 1993, kafin a jinkirta shari'ar kuma a sake tsara ta a ranar 10 ga Janairun 1994.

Shari'ar Ariffin Agas

A ranar 10 ga watan Janairun shekara ta 1994, Ariffin Agas mai shekaru 26 ya tsaya a gaban shari'a a Babban Kotun Kuala Lumpur saboda kisan gillar 'yan uwan Talwar da Natalia Fernandes . An nada alƙali guda ɗaya Datuk Syed Ahmad Idid da juriya na mambobi bakwai, wanda ya kunshi maza biyar da mata biyu, don jagorantar shari'ar kisan kai. A karkashin dokokin Malaysia da suka gabata, kafin a soke gwajin juriya a shekarar 1995, idan juriya ta same shi da laifin kisan kai, ko dai ta hanyar rinjaye ko yanke shawara ɗaya, za a yanke wa Ariffin hukuncin kisa a karkashin Sashe na 302 na Dokar Shari'ar Malaysia.

Masanin ilimin likitanci Dokta Abdul Rahman Yusof na Asibitin Kuala Lumpur, wanda ya gudanar da binciken gawawwakin wadanda abin ya shafa, ya ba da shaida cewa an kashe wadanda abin ya rutsa da su da kayan aiki, kodayake bai iya gano ainihin lokacin mutuwarsu ba. A game da Arjun Talwar mai shekaru bakwai, ya mutu daga zubar da jini a cikin kwakwalwa saboda bugun jini da yawa wanda ya karye kwanyar sa kuma ya lalata ƙwayoyin kwakwalwarsa. Babban ɗan'uwan Arjun, Kabir Talwar mai shekaru 11, an buge shi sau da yawa a fuska da kai, wanda ya karye tushe na kwanyarsa kuma ya haifar da zubar da jini sosai, kuma bakin ya zubar da jinin ya rufe hanyoyin iska na Kabir; Raunin Kabir gabaɗaya ya isa a cikin yanayi na yau da kullun don haifar da mutuwa. Masana kimiyya sun tabbatar da cewa daga hakora biyar na Kabir da aka samu a wurin aikata laifuka, an yi amfani da karfi mai tsanani a kan yaron, har ya kai ga cewa kwatangwalo ya karye kuma biyar daga cikin hakora sun ɓace, kuma babu wani raunin da ya samu ta hanyar faduwa. A ƙarshe, don mutuwar Natalia, raunin da ya faru a fuskarta ya kasance mai kisa sosai har ya sa fuskarta ta karye sosai kuma bakinta ya zubar da jini sosai, kuma ya gudana cikin hanyoyin iska, wanda ya hana iska shiga cikin huhu, wanda ya ƙunshi kusan 250cc na jini a cikinsu. Lauyan Ariffin K. Balaguru ya yi ƙoƙari ya tayar da shakku cewa rahotanni na likitan sun kasance marasa ma'ana kuma ba a yi su yadda ya kamata ba, zargin da Dokta Abdul Rahman ya musanta. Wani likitan likitan likitoci Dokta Primulapathi Jaya ya tabbatar da cewa tufafin tsaro na Ariffin ya shafa da jinin wadanda abin ya shafa.

Masu gabatar da kara, karkashin jagorancin Tun Abdul Majid Tun Hamzah da AC Fernandes, sun zargi Ariffin, saboda dalilan da ba a sani ba, ya kai hari ga dangin Talwar da Natalia tare da allon yanka da duwatsu kuma ya buge su, wanda ya haifar da mutuwar yara maza da baiwa kafin su jefa jikinsu cikin tankin septic. An gwada allon yankan da aka warke a wurin kuma tabo da aka samu a kan allon ya ƙunshi DNA na wadanda abin ya shafa. Suneeta Talwar, wanda ya tsira daga shari'ar, ya shaida cewa Ariffin ta kai mata hari da farko ta hanyar bugawa a goshi kuma an tilasta mata ta gudu daga gidan ita kadai.

David Raymond Frediani, mai ba da inshora da maƙwabcin Suneeta wanda ta nemi taimako daga gare shi ya tabbatar da shaidar Suneeta, yayin da ya shaida cewa kafin kisan kai, Ariffin shine kadai mutumin da ya ga yana yawo a waje da gidan kuma David ya shaida cewa ya ji kururuwa daga gidan Talwars kuma Suneeta ta kuma gaya masa cewa jami'anta ta kai mata hari. Wan Phen Martin, makwabciyar Talwars, ta shaida cewa ta ji Suneeta, wanda ta yi abota da shi a baya, tana ihu neman taimako kuma ta ga jini a gidan lokacin da ta je duba halin da ake ciki. Tay Su Lin, wani makwabcin dangin Talwar, ya ba da shaida cewa ta ji kururuwa don taimako daga gidan a lokacin kisan. Rakesh Talwar, wanda ya rushe a kotu yayin da yake shaida, ya bayyana cewa ya fara daukar ma'aikatan tsaro aiki bayan wani sata da ya faru a gidansa a ƙarshen 1990, kuma Ariffin ya kasance mai tsaron agaji da aka sanya shi a cikin bungalow jim kadan kafin ya tafi London a wannan dare lokacin da Ariffin ya kashe 'ya'yansa maza da baiwa.

Mai kula da Ariffin M Ramachandran ya kuma shaida cewa ba da daɗewa ba bayan kisan, ya ga Ariffin ya ɗauke shi daga motarsa, kuma ya ga Arifin yana jefa wuka daga cikin motar, kuma Ariffin ya ce ya gaya masa a cikin Malay, "Saya Great", wanda ke nufin "Dole ne in yi", a kaikaice yana nufin sa hannu a cikin kisan. Kwamishinan 'yan sanda Majid Jaafar ya ba da shaida cewa Ariffin ya kai su wurin da aka sami gawarwakin bayan ya tambaye shi inda wadanda aka kashe uku suke.

Koyaya, a tsakiyar shari'ar Ariffin, an gudanar da shari'a a cikin shari'a, yayin da lauyan Ariffin ya yi ƙoƙarin tayar da shakku cewa lokacin da Corporal Majid ya fara tambayarsa game da kisan kai, Ariffin ba a hannun 'yan sanda ba kuma ba a yarda da shi ba bisa ga Sashe na 27 na Dokar Shaida. A ƙarshe, kotun shari'a ta yanke hukuncin cewa maganganun sun yarda yayin da aka yi su yayin da Ariffin ke cikin kulawar 'yan sanda, kuma an dauki Corporal Majid a matsayin jami'in' yan sanda na halal lokacin da ya tambayi Ariffin game da kisan.

A ƙarshen shari'ar mai gabatar da kara, kotun shari'a ta yanke hukuncin cewa an kafa shari'ar da aka yi wa Ariffin, wanda aka umarce shi da ya tsaya ya kare shi. Ariffin ya musanta cewa ya kashe Natalia da 'yan uwan Talwar, yana mai da'awar cewa rukuni ne na maza uku masu dauke da makamai na kasar Sin wadanda suka kai hari kuma suka kashe wadanda aka kashe uku, kuma ya bayyana cewa mutanen da ke dauke da bindiga da wuka sun yi masa barazana, kuma sun tilasta masa taimakawa uku don zubar da gawawwakin wadanda abin ya shafa. Ariffin ya yi iƙirarin cewa ba shi da wani dalili na aikata kisan kai don farawa, kuma bai kasance mai hikima game da dalilin da ya sa mazajen kasar Sin suka kashe yara maza da baiwa ba. Masu gabatar da kara sun nemi su karyata cewa Ariffin ba gaskiya ba ne kuma sun shirya wanzuwar maza uku na kasar Sin don ya wanke shi daga laifinsa.

A ranar 28 ga watan Maris na shekara ta 1994, bisa ga hukuncin juriya mai mambobi bakwai da aka bayar kwana biyu da suka gabata bayan fiye da sa'o'i hudu na tattaunawa, an sami Ariffin da laifin aikata kisan kai ta hanyar yanke shawara mafi rinjaye na shida zuwa ɗaya, kuma juriya ta ba da shawarar hukuncin kisa guda uku, ɗaya ga kowane kisan kai wanda aka sami Ariffin laifi. Mai shari'a Datuk Syed Ahmad Idid, daidai da hukuncin juriya, ya yanke wa Ariffin hukunci kamar yadda ake tuhuma bayan ya yarda da binciken da suka yi, kuma ya yanke masa hukuncin kisa ta hanyar ratayewa.